Which of these 2 players would you have on your team?

I would take Barry Sanders and Marshall Faulk. Barry Sanders is either one of, if not THE, best RB in NFL history. He made people miss that had no business missing. He had a rare combination of power and finesse that all RBs try to replicate. I would take Marshall Faulk because of the versatility he brings to the table. He could do anything you asked him to. If the coach needed him to catch out of the backfield, he caught the ball. If the coach need him to run, he did that too, very, very well.